Saturday, November 05, 2005

A Little Girl In A Dead Guru's Hell

File under: Book Reviews and Wackadoo Gurus

We’ve just finished reading All the Fishes Come Home to Roost, the memoir of a young girl yanked out of her home in America, only to be taken to a desert wasteland backwater in India and the ashram of a dead, wackadoo guru she never believed in. It’s full of funny and yet startlingly sad recollections and many examples of the ridiculous things people are willing to accept about their supposedly divine gurus—and the twisted justifications they come up with for those gurus’ twisted behavior:
Baba had thrown a plate across the dining room table because he demanded total, unquestioning, to-the-letter obedience, and a mandali [devotee] had given him a white plate instead of the blue one he’d asked for. Paribanu said that Baba’s willingness to discipline his mandali [devotees] proved how much he loved them.
Either that or he was a raging asshole. Not incompatible with enlightenment, but not always the outpouring of pure love a hapless devotee wants to believe it is.

Obviously, the guy was drunk on his own power, as evidenced by this story:
“Baba asked us if we were ready to give him true obedience,” continued Nona. “Of course, we all said we were. He asked us if we’d give up our money, our jobs, even our lives for him. We all said we would. Then one by one, Baba asked us if we would be willing to kill our relatives or loved ones if he ordered us to.”
When you hear the story of Baba’s “enlightenment,” you begin to understand just how much of a nutbag the guy was, as if believing he was the reincarnation of Jesus Christ and every other major religious figure weren’t evidence enough:
The holy man pitched a rock at the dazed boy’s forehead. Merwan [Baba] promptly declared that he had become enlightened... For some time after the first blow, Baba banged his head against the floor until his forehead bled and all his teeth were knocked loose.
Rachel Manija Brown’s memoir is a great read for anyone interested in the psychosocial dynamics of divine gurudom and the complete abandonment of reason it often engenders. As sad as her life was in India, we thoroughly enjoyed reading about it, and the world is a slightly less insane place for her having shared it with us. We highly recommend All the Fishes Come Home to Roost and give it 4 out of 5 turbans.


At 11/05/2005 3:21 PM, Blogger Anonymouse said...

Is this Baba dude aware of the fact that Zappa's moustache is trademarked by the Zappa Family Trust? (re: the picture on his site) Although it's not exactly the same, he's skating on thin ice, man.

At 11/05/2005 4:10 PM, Blogger jody said...

But Dweeze, Meher Baba predates Zappaji. If anything, it's where Frank got his style. I'd keep this thing under my hat. It may give his people the idea to sue the ZFT to get their trademark back.

That said, I think Zappa wears it much better. As much of a freak as he was, he wasn't out on 500-yard limb with the exorbitant claims of divinity that Meher Baba was making. That puts Frank way ahead of him in my book.

At 11/05/2005 7:18 PM, Blogger Anonymouse said...

No worries...Meher Baba's people would never make it past the Utility Muffin Research Kitchen.
There's some pretty scary *mothers* in there.

At 7/22/2007 1:14 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

meher baba was a great guru sidha yes he was a little eccentric but he was great indeed.other saints of india thought meher baba was a great guru including upasani maharaj one of his gurus,i think meher baba was great because he was a saint and God realized who cares what people like you and others who sit at home and never actually do meet any great indian saints.i enjoy reading your pages they are well informed and funny,the sidhas of india are big enough to enjoy criticisim.

At 2/23/2010 7:26 AM, Blogger Josey said...

Great website. Plan to come and read more. It is pretty scary what gurus and organizations can do to people.

I have a blog on the dangers of meditation, here:

and then a website was created to expose yet another cult. It is pretty new:


Post a Comment

<< Home